Lucky you, birdy! We really did try to read Beowulf and Chaucer in their original language, with translations provided as well. I just wish then I could have heard it read aloud by someone skilled, but that was in high school, so our teachers, the (H)nuns, tried but weren't quite up to it, either. They were used to teaching French and Latin, which in some cases, did help a bit in other areas.
As to "TPPOTHM", that would be an interesting query. I imagine it also might depend which other language the people already knew, and how close they were to English roots. IQ might also be a factor, and facility with language as a whole, rather than someone better at math. Hmmm.